Whats the worst Tom Clancy game ever?

[KoS.Rebel]

Name the worst game that has come out of Tom Clancy. I for one vote Ghost Recon.

[Typhy]

:Raises hand:, here's another vote for Ghost Recon.

[*DAMN Hazard]

I don't mean to jump on the RS player band wagon but I can't really judge R6 and out of RS, GhR, and RvS, I have to vote GhR as the worst.

[crypt]

All good in my mind. Since someone has to defend GhR I guess I'll go with it till the end.

[Cutter]

for comps i'd vote ghr. overall i'd have to say splinter cell.

[Toxic::Joka]

Id have to go with RS

[Mr. Lothario]

     Well, on the Mac, definitely Ghost Recon. If we'd had a solid port of all of Red Storm's games, the decision might or might not be so cut-and-dried. But as things stand, Ghost Recon was easily the worst.

[spike]

doesn't this thread toe the line of blatent flaming? i mean, there are obvious factions of ghr and rs, and both are pretty set in their ways and ideas, and this thread is just blatently rejecting one of those ideas. i dunno, its pretty far out there, it was just a thought.

[BFG]

Looks like the traditional RS/R6 guys having a GhR bashing event... Having played R6, RS, GhR, RvS and soon (hopfully) SC id say none of them suck. Each one has its good merits and bad merits. If any one were to be bad id say the Original R6 - but thats becasue i was playing RS when i first played R6 and it simply couldn't stand up to RS at all... GhR does not suck. Hell i wonder really how people can compare the games they are so different. RS and GhR are just non comparable.

[Noto]

RS and R6 are better pieces of software, but I think Ghost Recon is a better game.  RvS kind of blows and could have been much better than it is.  I actually can't wait until GhR2 comes out.  Hopefully they have learned their lesson when porting games and will deliver a much needed strategy/team play game.

All in all, the best game, by far, is Action Quake.



.::|N| Noto

[S.p.i.d.e.r.]

As a constant player of GhR, I can easily say it is the worst so far.

[SAR(VoLaTile)]

I personally only like ghr, and hate the rest  

[|MP|Nomad]

Worst Game ever for Tom C. is hands down, Sum of All Fears for GC.

[Saberian 3000]

I would have to go with R6 being the crap, just for the fact that you couldn't lean around corners.  That always blew serious ass in my mind.   As for RS, it was a good game in it's time but being only OS9 was it's serious drawback.  and as for Ghr, well, the gameplay was more team oriented over single player standoffs like RS.  Ghr's main downfall was the many possible glitches in the end.  Rvs is great all around but has minor issues with needing serious processing speed to truly enjoy the game.  But in the end I would have to go with R6 for sure being the crap of the bunch.

:MoD:Saberian

[BTs_Mysterio]

I think the worst game is GhR. Also by far the worst player of Tom Clancy games is hands down Typhy.  

[Ace]

As one of the few people here who has played significant amounts of all 4 Clancy games on the Mac, I must say that RS is by far the lamest. It was a wannabe R6 except it was slow, had shitty guns, and had shitty maps.

[PsYcO aSsAsSiN]

Sum of All Fears, hands down. All they did for this game was take the Ghost Recon interface and give it a R6/RS feel to it. Very little effort put into this game and a huge waste of money for anyone who actually bought it.

[Supernatural Pie]

Splinter Cell. Had so much potential... but the graphics and cool tidbits thrown in just can't make a game that's that linear any fun.

Now, if we're talking R6/RS/GhR/RvS, it's GhR.

[tasty]

I'm going to agree with Ace and say Rogue Spear. What a bloated piece of disappointing shit that game was. The gameplay was only a fraction of what R6's was. I think GhR is a more solid game even though I don't like it that much either.

[*DAMN Mauti]

In my opinion Rogue Spear was by far the worst part of Tom Clancy games. The only thing I really liked was the possibility of armpatches, a nice mod interface and the Black Hawk Down mod which was one of my favourites together with the modified CS Assault map and the Counterstrike2 mod(proximity mines ). But out of the box RS never attracted me.

Ghost Recon is and was an awesome game. Finally teamwork was really required - no more I can do it all alone. Extreme well done camouflage and well balanced weapons contrary to RS were the PDW owned all. Further the sound atmosphere in GhR is unbeaten; I love it when a M60 shoots over your head and you can almost feel the heat of the amunition. The only drawback is/was my iMac but with my new G5 I gonna play it again. There are so cool missions and mods...

Rainbow Six is still one of my gameplay favourites for the game inbetween because it is the most arcade like shooter. Extreme simple and much faster than Rogue Spear with more balanced weapons. Yep it crashes(during hosting) a lot and the graphics are outdated but R6 is still a game you can start and play for 5 mins without any start up errors and preferences crashes contrary to RS.

Just my opinion.

Bye,

Mauti