*DAMN R6 Forum

*DAMN R6 Community => General Gossip => Topic started by: The Golden Shark on September 22, 2004, 06:23:37 am



Title: Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: The Golden Shark on September 22, 2004, 06:23:37 am
i have some unconfirmed reports from some people on the inside that they might anounce the draft in spring 04. i have no links, nothing in writing. Take it or leave it.


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: c| Spetsnaz. on September 22, 2004, 06:37:43 am
I think your reports are wrong.


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: BTs_Lee.Harvey on September 22, 2004, 06:48:30 am
i have some unconfirmed reports from some people on the inside that they might anounce the draft in spring 04. i have no links, nothing in writing. Take it or leave it.

Well thank god The spring of 04 has already passed....................


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: *DAMN Bondo on September 22, 2004, 07:33:48 am
There is a ton of chatter about a draft next year. One that allegedly will not discriminate based on sex or class (though the rich always find a way around things.)

As for the thread's question of would I dodge. A year ago I might have said yes...now I think I would go ahead (though I might get out based on physical things or be non-combat) even though I do not support the cause.


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: BFG on September 22, 2004, 10:16:15 am
Brrr yeah there is a bit of one isn't there. hold on i'll shut the door.


Ahh much better. Ok Draft? what draft? who when why how? inside where, draft of what??


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: spike on September 22, 2004, 03:08:42 pm
Luckily BFG, all you will have to do is sit and watch as us eligible american males are picked off one by one.


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: BFG on September 22, 2004, 06:13:07 pm
Ohh drafting! Wow i thought bush was stupid but wouldn't that really be a most inpressive way to kick yourself in the knackers, smack your head on your ass and choke on a pretzel  way to loose the elections??


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: BTs_GhostSniper on September 22, 2004, 07:07:29 pm
There isn't going to be a draft.  It is just left-wing crap being thrown out there to make Bush look bad before the election.  And hell, with the way Democrats are into forgery these days, they can make up documents that say just about anything.


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: BFG on September 22, 2004, 07:46:08 pm
Bush has done a good enough job at making himself look totally  crap GS without help from anyone else. And the Democrats are into forgery? There i was thinking that it was Bush's records of service that kept appearing out of the white house in different contradictory versions as and when the time demanded?


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: KoS.Rebel on September 22, 2004, 08:04:34 pm
Although im not a fan of the draft, it does not scare me and i would serve my country.


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: BFG on September 22, 2004, 08:11:05 pm
Quote
it does not scare me

Being ordered to kill people, to kill people for reasons that you do not agree with? to be in a possition where you may unintentionally kill innocent civilians?

And it dosn't scare you?


Patriots often say they will serve their country... would they die for it?


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: BTs_GhostSniper on September 22, 2004, 08:12:37 pm
Patriots often say they will serve their country... would they die for it?

In a heartbeat.


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: KoS.Rebel on September 22, 2004, 08:30:15 pm
If it came to that then yes. If u handed me a gun right now, and told me to kill 3 iraquis infront of me, id do it in heart beat


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: crypt on September 22, 2004, 08:55:23 pm
This was one of the main reasons I was contemplating joining anyway. That way, I'd be viewed as volunteering rather than drafted.
I'd do the same, Rebel. Perhaps it takes an American to realize the true meaning of Patriotism. Maybe I am wrong, though.


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: BTs_Lee.Harvey on September 22, 2004, 08:56:55 pm
i have some unconfirmed reports from some people on the inside that they might anounce the draft in spring 04. i have no links, nothing in writing. Take it or leave it.




I guess no one noticed that he put
Quote
might anounce the draft in spring 04

if thats the case.. then it was a lie.. b/c the spring of 04 was a few months back.. if i remeber corectly.. unless time is going backwards ???


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: crypt on September 22, 2004, 09:00:28 pm
Typo, possibly. With all the brave young men and women enlisting due to all the terrorist activity recently, I highly doubt they would need a draft.


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: KoS.Rebel on September 22, 2004, 09:14:15 pm
Yes Crypt it does. Most of these people on these forums that claim to be american arent. The motto i live by is Love it, or Leave it. Speaks for itself.


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: Mr. Lothario on September 22, 2004, 09:19:07 pm
     Heh. I would be willing to go to war against a real enemy. Hitler? Sign me up. The Iraqi oilfields and "weapons of mass destruction-related program activities"? Fuck off. The only enemy in Iraq is the one we've created by attacking a country that was doing nothing to us.


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: c| Lone-Wolf on September 22, 2004, 09:40:06 pm
Amen Loth.


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: PsYcO aSsAsSiN on September 22, 2004, 09:44:59 pm
The only thing about a draft that has happened recently was the bill that congressional Democrats introduced trying to institute a draft that was non-discriminatory.


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: BFG on September 22, 2004, 11:08:33 pm
Loth hit it spot on but something u said rebel....

Quote
If u handed me a gun right now, and told me to kill 3 iraquis infront of me, id do it in heart beat

There is a 14 year old boy, his mother and father standing infront of you. they are Iraqi's (i assume you were reffering to iraq) they are part of the crowd that has gathered around the wreckage of a humvee that has been destroyed by a roadside bomb. Your Sergeant or equivlent is freaking crazy and has orderd you to open fire on the crowd...

I hope you never ever join the military for the sake of yourself and the US army and the poor bastards that have to face gung ho kids rushing off to fight a war on terrorism without thinking about it. It only makes the jobs of the soldiers who have their heads screwed on and their minds and hearts in the right places, jobs so much harder.

Quote
Perhaps it takes an American to realize the true meaning of Patriotism. Maybe I am wrong, though.

Maybe you are. I think the true meaning of Patriotism was shown by people like the French resistance who put their lives the lives of their family and friends on the wire to fight for their country against the Germans. That is Patriotism, not some kid saying he'd go shoot Iraqi civilians if some idiot told him to.

There is a difference between WWII and Bush's "war against terrorism"


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: BTs_GhostSniper on September 22, 2004, 11:26:39 pm
Quote
If u handed me a gun right now, and told me to kill 3 iraquis infront of me, id do it in heart beat

There is a 14 year old boy, his mother and father standing infront of you. they are Iraqi's (i assume you were reffering to iraq) they are part of the crowd that has gathered around the wreckage of a humvee that has been destroyed by a roadside bomb. Your Sergeant or equivlent is freaking crazy and has orderd you to open fire on the crowd...

That is total BS.  That shit happens in the movies, and although in some EXTREMELY rare cases it has happened in the past, it is by far not the norm for the U.S. Military.  In those rare cases where civilians were killed, it was almost always by accident, not by some rogue militants issuing illegal orders as you have described here.  BFG, you have never served in the military; do not make the mistake of tarnishing the honor of the military I served in for your stupid political arguments.


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: BFG on September 22, 2004, 11:41:46 pm
It wasn't ment to be a realistic situation GS - Christ im only too well aware its not like the Hollywood movies - that wasn't the point i was tryiing to make. It was Rebel basically saying that he would quite happily shoot iraqi's if someone told him to.

Individual US soldiers have managed to tarnish it themselves without any help from anyone else.

Ps... Why did that helicopter fire a missile into a crowd of demintrators the other week? bet that wasn't covered much by the  media... Perhaps you haven't seen the footage of the camermans footage filming a reporter - seeing the explosion that kills him right their in front of the camera?


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: BTs_GhostSniper on September 22, 2004, 11:52:18 pm
Individual US soldiers have managed to tarnish it themselves without any help from anyone else.

Sure, individuals have always brought dishonor upon themselves....but don't make it sound like it is common practice for the U.S. Military....because it isn't.

Ps... Why did that helicopter fire a missile into a crowd of demintrators the other week? bet that wasn't covered much by the  media... Perhaps you haven't seen the footage of the camermans footage filming a reporter - seeing the explosion that kills him right their in front of the camera?

Yes, it was covered by our media here....you forget that the U.S. Media is every bit as liberal and twisted as your own media.  And who knows why that helicopter fired into the crowd...could have been a miscalculation, an accident, or just plain stupidity on his part....doesn't mean some higher up ordered him to do it.  And besides that WE do NOT know the whole story....you only get the part of the story that the media lets you get.  Which in most cases is a gross distortion of the facts.


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: crypt on September 23, 2004, 01:59:58 am
Maybe you are. I think the true meaning of Patriotism was shown by people like the French resistance who put their lives the lives of their family and friends on the wire to fight for their country against the Germans. That is Patriotism, not some kid saying he'd go shoot Iraqi civilians if some idiot told him to.

There is a difference between WWII and Bush's "war against terrorism"

What about the 2000+ Americans and other troops that saved their ass?

All I was trying to say is that if my country were to ask me and go out there and defend it, I would, as would most other young americans.


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: Mr. Lothario on September 23, 2004, 02:12:06 am
     If there were something to defend against, I would gladly go.


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: BFG on September 23, 2004, 02:24:28 am
Yes Crypt i totally agree, all those americans, and the Canadians, and every other man and woman who put their lives on the line as they did.

Quote
if my country were to ask me and go out there and defend it, I would, as would most other young americans.

To go out there, somewhere else to defend your country? OK i get your point but if we're refering to iraq then its not a case of defending your country as Bush would have you belive, why, because iraq had nothing to do with september 11th or Al-Quieda or Osama or any of it. Invading iraq had nothing to do with Defending America the closest you could get to that statment was that Invading iraq had somthing to do with Defending Americas oil interests... thats about it.

Quote
Yes, it was covered by our media here....you forget that the U.S. Media is every bit as liberal and twisted as your own media
Not that you'd agree but id probably say thats not the case - we have people like the BBC who are widely regarded as being one of the best and most professional news networks in the world. We have our shit as well thanks to Rupport Murdoch but dosn't everyone. but it still begs the question.. its not the first time somthing like this has happend and most likely not the last


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: The Golden Shark on September 23, 2004, 02:33:01 am
i have some unconfirmed reports from some people on the inside that they might anounce the draft in spring 04. i have no links, nothing in writing. Take it or leave it.




I guess no one noticed that he put
Quote
might anounce the draft in spring 04

if thats the case.. then it was a lie.. b/c the spring of 04 was a few months back.. if i remeber corectly.. unless time is going backwards ???

obviously, this post has weeded out the ingnorant of common sense from the intellegent people who can figure out a typo, and make the appropriate mental corrections before posting.

your 2 posts added together make you look like an ass.

For THOSE of you who can't seem to get a grasp on what i was saying. i ment '05


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: jn.loudnotes on September 23, 2004, 02:38:33 am
The difference between Loth's totally tenable position and that of those who would willingly waste their lives in any situation is one of independent thought.

If, like Loth, you are so confident in your own reason and judgment that you prefer it to that of your elected leaders, you cannot absolutely say that you would go in any draft.  There's an issue of trust and faith in the president and congress that comes up.

Since when did patriotism in and of itself become such a positive thing?  It is frighteningly close to nationalism - and that sort of blind demagoguery has led to huge tragedy in the past.  While I applaud a willingness to serve the nation - it is foolhardy to suggest that it is honorable to follow orders under all circumstances.  Sometimes the greatest love of country is to know when to say "no."

To GS - While I commend your military service, answer me this.  How do you rationalize killing another human being after being ordered to do so?  Do you always know why you are killing "the enemy"?  Is it possible that the instruction to kill from your superior officer is unjustified?  Ultimately, do you trust him, his superiors, and your government above your own understanding?

If the answer is yes, why?


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: BFG on September 23, 2004, 02:47:00 am
Quote
To GS - While I commend your military service, answer me this.? How do you rationalize killing another human being after being ordered to do so?? Do you always know why you are killing "the enemy"?? Is it possible that the instruction to kill from your superior officer is unjustified?? Ultimately, do you trust him, his superiors, and your government above your own understanding?

If the answer is yes, why?

... Becasue he is a Patriot? ;)


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: KoS.Rebel on September 23, 2004, 02:51:34 am
BFG, why dont we put this into a new perspective really quick. Lets say that we were invaded by some country, for example Russia. Now, if a russian tank was goin down ur street and got blown up by mines placed by people that lived by you, and you ran outside with the rest of them and celebrated, dont you think that a russian heli is justified by shooting a missile at you? if you dont recall, in that instance you speak of, those people that swarmed the blown up ATV were waving terrorist regime flags. I do believe that Iraq is now overdue and that troops should be withdrawn in steps, but we cannot become an isolationist country again, that hurts us as a whole. I feel there is a better way to go about rooting out terrorism, but just leavin guys in the country to protect it isnt right. But what i do know is that Kerry's plans, although EXTREMELY vague (visit the John Kerry website and read about his "plans"), call for the withdrawal of troops and from what it sounds like, the beginning of isolationism. We tried it once pre ww2 and it didnt work out. What people on the forums dont realize is you CANNOT change a persons views, everyone has their own and they will not change. I dont want to change your views im just justifying mine.


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: Cossack on September 23, 2004, 02:56:49 am
If the enemy is shooting at you and he is confirmed OPFOR, you shoot at him. If the officer tells you to do so, then you better fucking shoot at him because you will get in deep shit for disobeying an order.

If you are ordered to kill a bunch of innocents. If you have an officer like Lt Calley (Mai Lai massacre) then it is your duty as a human being to disobey him. Tell your superiors if he gives you any shit. Then again, things arent always black and white out there.

Edit: Posted after Rebel's post. No Rebel, it is not justified to kill unarmed civilians, even if they are celebrating the destruction or death of one of your men. That is clearly against the Geneva Convention.


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: BFG on September 23, 2004, 03:04:33 am
Justified in shooting a missile at civilians? no i can't say i do. And i didn't know anyting about a "terrorist regime flag" unless you mean they were flying the Iraqi flag? it wasn't a terrorist regime though. And u can't justify shooting missiles at a crowd becasue they were waving flags that you don't like.

Quote
I feel there is a better way to go about rooting out terrorism, but just leavin guys in the country to protect it isnt right.

I agree. Although i think this all went wrong when the invasion was rushed - there seems to have been no plan or strategy to sort the country out afterwards... its like everyone said before - if you go in and remove the power then you have to stay there and create a new power as if you move out you leave a power vacume and you open Iraq to anyone... .and that is what has happend. A power vacume has been created and is being filled by islamic insurgents..


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: BTs_GhostSniper on September 23, 2004, 04:09:32 am
To GS - While I commend your military service, answer me this.  How do you rationalize killing another human being after being ordered to do so?  Do you always know why you are killing "the enemy"?  Is it possible that the instruction to kill from your superior officer is unjustified?  Ultimately, do you trust him, his superiors, and your government above your own understanding?

If the answer is yes, why?

In war, you kill the enemy.  You kill the enemy when he fires upon you.  You kill the enemy when your superiors tell you to.  No, you don't always know WHY you are killing the enemy....although these days it is rare that you wouldn't know.  But yes, you must trust your superiors and follow their orders (unless the order is grossly illegal...another rare situation).  I personally have been in this situation, and when it comes to killing another person, I am able to do so without hesitation....even though it isn't something I like to do....you must defend yourself and your men.  To not kill in that situation would be unthinkable.  These days the U.S. Military gives the enemy combatants plenty of time to surrender....we even go to the extent of dropping thousands of leaflets from airplanes telling them we are coming and they better throw down their weapons and run or surrender.  If they are still there after all that, then they want to fight.[/size]


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: spike on September 23, 2004, 04:28:50 am
GS the leaflets aint nothing new. They happened in WWII, they happened in WWI, and I'm sure there has been some form of leaflets for hundreds of years.


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: jn.loudnotes on September 23, 2004, 04:32:33 am
Quote
In war, you kill the enemy.? You kill the enemy when he fires upon you.? You kill the enemy when your superiors tell you to.? No, you don't always know WHY you are killing the enemy....although these days it is rare that you wouldn't know.? But yes, you must trust your superiors and follow their orders (unless the order is grossly illegal...another rare situation).? I personally have been in this situation, and when it comes to killing another person, I am able to do so without hesitation....even though it isn't something I like to do....you must defend yourself and your men.

Hypothethically -

Imagine you are in a situation where your own observation and experience dictates that for whatever reason you should not kill as instructed.  I can think of several that would violate my own personal principles without being "grossly illegal."  Let's say for example that you and your comrades are not in any danger at the time, but you have the opportunity to kill a potential enemy.  If your conscience dictates that you should not murder the person, but you are ordered to do so by superiors - by the president even - would you do it?

Aren't you again basing your definition of the enemy on faith in your superiors?  What if - and maybe this would never cross your mind, but it certainly would the minds of many equally patriotic draftees - what if the enemy is not really deserving of death, what if their cause is just - what if they have reason to fight.  Can the U.S. government be wrong, when they have committed to war?


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: BTs_GhostSniper on September 23, 2004, 04:33:57 am
GS the leaflets aint nothing new. They happened in WWII, they happened in WWI, and I'm sure there has been some form of leaflets for hundreds of years.

The way we drop them today is TOTALLY new.  We drop them by the millions....if you don't see one of these, you are just blind.  Back in the old days, we tried to drop enough for everyone to see them, but it just never happened in the quantities we could manage.  Today we spend millions of dollars on trying to get the enemy to give up and surrender, or to simply run away.  I have a stack of the ones my father dropped on Iraqi positions during the first Gulf War.[/size]


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: jn.loudnotes on September 23, 2004, 04:40:00 am
So what?  Is it possible that the soldiers believe their cause is worth fighting for?  After all, we are invading their country - just because they ignore leaflets in an attempt to defend themselves doesn't mean they deserve to die.


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: BTs_GhostSniper on September 23, 2004, 04:42:41 am
So what?  Is it possible that the soldiers believe their cause is worth fighting for?  After all, we are invading their country - just because they ignore leaflets in an attempt to defend themselves doesn't mean they deserve to die.

OMG...are you really John Kerry in disguise???[/size]


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: jn.loudnotes on September 23, 2004, 04:58:35 am
Yes GhostSniper, I am actually John Kerry.  Since I've taken so much time and energy to debate with you, will you please vote for me out of respect?  Thank you.

Now that you've called me out, please explain to me what you find so objectionable about my refusal to countenance needless death, and questioning of those who cause it willingly.


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: BTs_GhostSniper on September 23, 2004, 05:10:33 am
Yes GhostSniper, I am actually John Kerry.  Since I've taken so much time and energy to debate with you, will you please vote for me out of respect?  Thank you.

Nope, sorry.  A vote for you is a vote for pure evill.[/size]

Now that you've called me out, please explain to me what you find so objectionable about my refusal to countenance needless death, and questioning of those who cause it willingly.

The deaths that have occurred are not "needless".  We are fighting the enemy on their soil so that they do not bring the war to our soil.  Someday you might understand that.  But then, you didn't understand that in Vietnam we were trying to stop the spread of Communism.  You know, there is still a nice Bust of you in the Hall of Heroes of Communism in Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam.[/size]


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: Supernatural Pie on September 23, 2004, 05:55:13 am
I've been wondering about the possibility of a draft for quite a while.

1). Just what exactly are the chances of the reinstitution of the draft?

2). What kind of public outcry would follow the reinstitution of the draft?


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: PsYcO aSsAsSiN on September 23, 2004, 07:05:46 am
I can't believe you numbnuts just saying that the attack helicopter fired into a crowd of civilians as if the only purpose was to kill civlians. The chopper was firing on a disabled bradley fighting vehicle to prevent the mob from pillaging its weapons and ammo cache inside - thus the violent explosion when it was struck by the rockets.

Although killing innocent civilians is unfortunate, they should have known that it is common practice for the military to do things like that to prevent looting - it was apparent that it was not the first time that some of them had been dancing around a disabled miltary vehicle.


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: *DAMN Bondo on September 23, 2004, 07:44:01 am
GhostSniper...your sentiment about what war is is nice...but who the "enemy" is isn't always clear. Like in Vietnam, the whole war was wrong, and by relation the Viet Cong were not enemy...they didn't deserve to die. Americans didn't deserve to die either but we, unlike the VC, choose to be in Vietnam, they were Vietnamese. To believe that an Iraqi resistance fighter is an enemy means you have to unconditionally believe that the US is right in being there. Now, you may be able to not consider the greater implication in order to follow orders, but I couldn't. It doesn't make me less heroic or patriotic.

Sin, protecting the ammo in the tank isn't worth 15 civilian lives and another hundred resistance/terror recruits. If you really want to prevent the ammo from being taken, put some men on the ground to clear the area of civilians.


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: BFG on September 23, 2004, 11:52:28 am
Quote
numbnuts just saying that the attack helicopter fired into a crowd of civilians as if the only purpose was to kill civlians. The chopper was firing on a disabled bradley fighting vehicle to prevent the mob from pillaging its weapons and ammo cache inside - thus the violent explosion when it was struck by the rockets.

Have you watched the video footage or heard the eye witness accounts?

And now murder is justified to prevent looting?


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: Mr. Lothario on September 23, 2004, 07:58:43 pm
     Assuming there was a Bradley, I've got to go with GS on this one. Whatever the reasons for the war, no matter why the guys are there fighting, once they're there, their first priority is the survival of them and their buddies. If the weapons and ammo had been left in the Bradley, there's a distinct possibility that they would have wound up being used against our troops. Interdicting those supplies by blowing them up would probably save some friendly lives, so it's a no-brainer.

     There's a lot of morality issues associated with firing into a crowd of noncombatants, whatever the reason, but if the pilot was shooting to destroy a Bradley, I can't impugn him. Presented with the possibility of saving friendly lives against the probability of taking "enemy" lives, most soldiers would make the same choice.


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: BFG on September 23, 2004, 10:10:13 pm
"I am a journalist. I'm dying, I'm dying," screamed Mazen al-Tumeizi, a correspondent for the Arabic television channel al-Arabiya, after shrapnel from a rocket fired by an American helicopter interrupted his live broadcast and slammed into his back.

Twelve others were killed and 61 wounded by rockets from two US helicopters on Haifa Street in central Baghdad. They had fired into a crowd milling around a burning Bradley fighting vehicle that had been hit by a rocket or bomb hours before.

It comes on one of Iraq's bloodiest days for weeks in which at least 110 people died in clashes around the country. The Health Ministry said the worst casualties were in Baghdad and in Tal Afar near the Syrian border, where 51 people died.

"The helicopter fired on the Bradley to destroy it after it had been hit earlier and it was on fire," said Major Phil Smith of the 1st Cavalry Division. "It was for the safety of the people around it."

Mr Tumeizi, a Palestinian, was the sixth Arab journalist to be killed by American troops since Baghdad was captured last year. The videotape of his last moments shows how Mr Tumeizi was killed during a live television broadcast, with the Bradley blazing in the distance and a crowd of young men celebrating its destruction, but it shows no reason why the helicopters should open fire.

Many of those hit by the rockets in Haifa Street, in a tough neighbourhood of tower blocks notorious as a centre of resistance to the occupation, were on their way to work. "We are just ordinary workers. We are just trying to live," said Haidar Yahyiah, 23, sobbing with pain from a broken leg as he lay in bed in nearby Karkh hospital.

He and others described how they had been woken by the sound of explosions in Haifa Street in the early dawn. They had been sleeping on the roofs because it is too hot in the Baghdad summer to sleep inside. They saw a vehicle on fire. But it was several hours later, at about 8am, that they sallied out.

By then US troops had already removed four lightly wounded soldiers from the Bradley. Young men and children had swarmed over the vehicle, cheering triumphantly, waving black flags and setting it ablaze again. The US military said that a Kiowa, a light reconnaissance and attack helicopter, fired rockets at the Bradley to destroy weapons and ammunition on board. But it is evident from the al-Arabiya video that the rockets landed among people standing or walking far away from the Bradley.

Hamid Ali Khadum was on his way to work when he was hit. "At first I thought I had just tripped over dead people but then I realised I was wounded myself," he said as he lay in Karkh hospital waiting for an operation on his heavily bandaged left leg. The rest of his body was peppered with shrapnel. A male nurse standing nearby said: "This happens not just in Haifa Street but in all Baghdad, and not just in Baghdad but in all Iraq."

The slaughter in Haifa Street took place only a few hundred yards from the heavily defended International Zone (what used to be called the Green Zone) which houses the headquarters of the Iraqi government and its American ally. It is a measure of the military failure of the US occupation that it has failed to assume control of this Sunni Muslim neighbourhood in the heart of the capital.

Early yesterday, insurgents fired more than a dozen rockets and mortars into the International Zone. The zone contains the US embassy and Saddam Hussein's Republican Palace.

There was violence elsewhere in Baghdad. Colonel Alaa Bashir, the police chief of the Yarmouk district in west Baghdad, was killed by a bomb while on patrol. A suicide bomber blew himself up in a vehicle packed with explosives at the gates to Abu Ghraib prison ? he was the only one to die. A US plane attacked a machine-gun team from the Mehdi Army in their stronghold in Sadr City in east Baghdad.


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: BTs_GhostSniper on September 23, 2004, 10:24:33 pm
Maybe next time those people, and the journalists, will learn their lesson and stay away from burning M2A1's.  I have no pity for people, especially journalists, who are loitering around in a war zone and get killed.  There had to be a better way to get to work than walking up next to a burning Bradley Fighting Vehicle.


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: *DAMN Bondo on September 24, 2004, 12:04:26 am
But it is evident from the al-Arabiya video that the rockets landed among people standing or walking far away from the Bradley.

Read this part again GS, they were not "up next to a burning Bradley Fighting Vehicle."

This was a massacre and a war crime, plain and simple. The US military should be held accountable so they see that they can't make this sort of mistake in the future. If no one forces the US to be careful in avoiding civilian deaths, they won't be. If the US was not an occupying force, they would consider a US soldier life worth trading for an Iraqi civilian life...just like in the US a soldiers life is supposed to be sacrificed to save civilians if one of them has to be put in that position. It is imperialistic to feel an American life is worth more than an Iraqi life.


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: BTs_GhostSniper on September 24, 2004, 12:08:09 am
But it is evident from the al-Arabiya video that the rockets landed among people standing or walking far away from the Bradley.

Read this part again GS, they were not "up next to a burning Bradley Fighting Vehicle."

This was a massacre and a war crime, plain and simple. The US military should be held accountable so they see that they can't make this sort of mistake in the future. If no one forces the US to be careful in avoiding civilian deaths, they won't be. If the US was not an occupying force, they would consider a US soldier life worth trading for an Iraqi civilian life...just like in the US a soldiers life is supposed to be sacrificed to save civilians if one of them has to be put in that position. It is imperialistic to feel an American life is worth more than an Iraqi life.

I think you need a good old fashioned dose of "Go Join the Military and see what it's like before you condemn others".


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: BFG on September 24, 2004, 12:08:56 am
Quote
Maybe next time those people, and the journalists, will learn their lesson and stay away from burning M2A1's.? I have no pity for people, especially journalists, who are loitering around in a war zone and get killed.? There had to be a better way to get to work than walking up next to a burning Bradley Fighting Vehicle.

You quite simply make me sick. I cannot belive you can be so emotionally dissattached.

Its not just a fucking war zone - IT IS WHERE PEOPLE LIVE. You know? PEOPLE - liveing human beings. Trying to live their lives. Saying that was just like the Israelis " oh its a war zone they shouldn't have been there" THEY FUCKING LIVE THERE. IT IS THEIR HOME, THEIR COUNTRY. WHERE THEY HAVE TO LIVE AND WORK.

 You just don't seem to have the mental or emotional capacity to put the two together. I can't even make sense of what im writing you enrage me so much.

But it is evident from the al-Arabiya video that the rockets landed among people standing or walking far away from the Bradley.

Can you not read? You twist everything. Rather than it being the fault of the american pilots - the guys that fired a missile which hit the civilians you blame the civilians for being there? You blame a journalist for trying to report what is happening? Are you fucking insane? But no, god bless your fucking military, those soldiers  couldn't possibly have done anything wrong - theres no need to even fucking appologies for killing those men women and children becasue it was their fault ??

As for reporting... Unlike all those US reporters who were "enbedded" with US troops and who managed to give you wonderfull news reports of troops marching past, more trooops marching past, the odd distant explosion, soldiers polishing their tanks... the rasiing of the american flag etc etc, some reporters actually try to get close to the people who are involved in the events unfurling - they are trying to let the rest of the world know what is going on - what really happens when an american bomb miss's its target and hits a civilian building - what really happens when young scared US troops open fire on a car at a roadblock becasue the family inside didn't understand what the US soldiers wanted them to do, what happens when a Bristish Convoy is attacked by american fighter jets.

You don't seem to like the truth, or what seems to be the truth, or anything that dosn't met your narrow minded religiouse view of the world yet its what we call freedom of speach over here - freedom of information and truth or as close to it as possible.

That reporter was doing a job - to show the rest of the world what was going on. I get the overwhelming feeling not to mention from your post you give the overwhelelming feeling that you don't like people reporting the truth - it damages your little "bubble world" of how fucking perfect you are. And you wont even begin to deal with or acept the existance of anything that even thinks about threatening that bubble.

"I am a journalist. I'm dying, I'm dying," screamed Mazen al-Tumeizi, a correspondent for the Arabic television channel al-Arabiya, after shrapnel from a rocket fired by an American helicopter interrupted his live broadcast and slammed into his back.



Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: BTs_GhostSniper on September 24, 2004, 12:11:58 am
Rather than it being the fault of the american pilots - the guys that fired a missile which hit the civilians you blame the civilians for being there? You blame a journalist for trying to report what is happening? Are you fucking insane? But no, god bless your fucking military, those soldiers  couldn't possibly have done anything wrong - theres no need to even fucking appologies for killing those men women and children becasue it was their fault ??

Tell you what....you start blaming the TERRORISTS for 9/11, instead of the United States, and I'll take a second look at this incident and decide if the pilots could be at blame.  Fair enough?


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: BFG on September 24, 2004, 12:15:03 am
Never thought otherwise - How could it be possible to blame anyone else but the guys that flew those planes into the towers? And i don't belive like you probably think i do that the Goverment decided to blow up the WTT to get an exuse to go to war.

However the reason why the men that hijacked planes can to that point where they were willing to die for a cause must go back a long way - and who lays the blame that has lead to people becoming this fanatical and extreame is anothe matter.


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: Aramarth on September 24, 2004, 01:04:44 am
Patriots often say they will serve their country... would they die for it?

I was ready to do just that at the age of 16. I decided then that I would charge a school shooter in a hearbeat. The strange part is, the only people I would have "helped" are the very same classmates who treated me disdainfully at times. There is a good check for all those who claim to be patriots out there. Would you die for those enemies of yours with whom you only share a flag?


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: BTs_GhostSniper on September 24, 2004, 01:38:56 am
I was ready to do just that at the age of 16. I decided then that I would charge a school shooter in a hearbeat. The strange part is, the only people I would have "helped" are the very same classmates who treated me disdainfully at times. There is a good check for all those who claim to be patriots out there. Would you die for those enemies of yours with whom you only share a flag?

Absolutely.  When it comes to war, it is like you and your brothers....you can beat the crap out of each other all day long, but as soon as the bully next door tries to do it, it's a whole different story.[/size]


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: *DAMN Bondo on September 24, 2004, 02:27:22 am
I think you need a good old fashioned dose of "Go Join the Military and see what it's like before you condemn others".

Using that logic I can't condemn Hitler without becoming a Nazi. I can't condemn Bin Laden without joining Al Queda. I can't condemn the Broncos for fumbling away last weekends game without playing on the team.


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: jn.loudnotes on September 24, 2004, 03:16:52 am
Fortunately all Kerry-voters are neo-nazi terrorists, and they're bad at football to boot, so you're in luck, Bondo!

By the way, why hasn't anyone here answered to the question, "would you die for your country?"

"NO, because I could help it out more alive"

I'm sure that doesn't apply to everyone, and maybe it's arrogant to think it applies to yourself, but it's got to apply to some people.  We wouldn't dream of sacrificing an Albert Einstein as an infantryman...


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: z][t-Rampage on September 24, 2004, 04:49:36 am
9/11? iraq? i think i missed a part of the news here. did iraq fund or instigate 9/11? i was pretty sure that osama binladen was behind this. did the u.s attack afganistan because iraq had been bad? im really missing the link to iraq here. the facts are simple are they are still showing themselves splendedly without the news even having to show us the facts. NO ONE HAS FOUND WEAPONS OF MASSDISTRUCTION. no one. or have they? plz enlighten me, because that was the reason to attack that country. that was the arguement by every politician backing the "war" to invade. the fact that Sadam hussein is a freak and a bastard is NOT a good enough reason for western countries to attack. because if it is, well then there are so many other countries in the world that have dictators that should be invaded and are quite as dangerous as Iraq was convinced to the public to be.  I have to admit that when i watch the news and some poor soul who has been beheaded is shown publicly and on display, i play with the thought of someone western doing the same. but then i come back to wtf did we go into iraq for? a chance of finding weapons? chemicals? chance does not cut it when  civilians are dying! wether they be u.s or arabic.  we have added to their poor excuse of hating the western civilisation. we are adding fuel to the fire. this is a process that has been stirring for a long long time and it does NOT only affect the u.s. and thats another problem i see with these discussions. they become u.s vs the rest of the world. that is not the case anymore. the u.s is NOT the only country that has gone to "war" on iraq, lets not forget that. i believe that every country with a  western system is a target, especially the ones that joined the "war". iraq to me is a fucked up excuse to go get the oil that the western way of life needs. i dont believe there is a conspiracy theory going on. i believe it comes down to money and big business. the business that we as matrealistic ppl must have in our lives. the gadgets we toy with, the fuel we need for everything, the brand name clothes and electronics that are must haves in the system that we have gotten so used too. we have gone to war on a poor fucking excuse and it does not cut it. we have gone to war because the western system has worked. me me me, money money money and more more more.

when 9/11 happened i was unfortunate enough to watch cnn as they showed it the first time. just fucking horrible. anyone in these forums will agree with that. going into afganistan and getting rid of the Taliban because they backed Osama Binladen. it was almost a must in my opinion. the u.s needed to act and they needed to act fast. but that was Afganistan and the EVIDENCE that Al-Qaeda had training  camps there.
But turning around to invade Iraq on MAYBE'S is a little vague for me. there is no evidence other than the country is exploding....just like Afganistan did many many years ago. just so u know, it used to be a very modern and "western" country.

This is not about the u.s anymore and its not about the safety of america. its about every western country in the world and the way of life that we have gotten used to.
And handling religion against religion is sure to fail.  Thats one of Bush's biggest faults, he thinks he has god on his side.....well news flash....So do the terrorists. who's god is the better one? or are they the same, just with different names that MEN have come up with. We need to seperate religion from politics and handle things in a humane way and not a coorporate one. cause this ship we call the world is sinking if we dont.


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: z][t-Neo on September 24, 2004, 11:49:57 am
and ofc ... who started/provoked that war? .. the US guys themselfs by supporting Irak, Israel and by bombing Bagdad in februar 2001.

How about bombing North Korea .. They have A weapons. btw. also supported by the USA in the Vietnam war !...!

And the Korea conflict is hot atm. They really change the status quo in Asia, cuz noone has such bombs prepared...
Ah... hold on. I got the answer. Korea has no Oil and the USA has strategic places in South Korea .. um.. so no need to bomb North Korea, too.

To sum up. The US conflicts are home-made. You support the countrys ... and instead saying thanks to you they do 9/11 ... Excuse me. But how can one be so stupid.

And ... what did ya president do in the first min after the WTC bombing ... oups... hell yeah. he went ahead reading a book for the little childrens. How cute.

This guy has more vacations than me and i am a student .. weird .. it seems you really want to have this guy.  :o

(sry, didnt have the time to read all statements .. maybe some are doubled here. sry than)


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: Brutha on September 24, 2004, 11:52:35 am
Well said ramps. I just want to add something here about Afghanisthan. When they were invaded by the soviet union, the militia was armed and trained by america. This was done because it was in their best interest to do so. The ppl of Afghanistan was never in the politicians minds when they aided them. And it became clear when the war ended, and the americans left, and let the weapons stay behind. They had armed a nation to fight a war for them, a war against communism. So what happens? Afghanistans warlords turn on eachother and Afghanistan was thrown into a civil war that lastet basicly untill america invaded(fighting goes on today too). The ppl never forgot how they got used, and got angry. N wonder really.

Now many of you out there might say that its not your problem that Afghanistan couldnt handle their own internal struggles and America should not be blamed for this. Well here is the thing: You train a man to kill, and when he has killed and the killing stops, what can he do? Killing is all he knows, and you trained him to do so. Dont you think you have the obligation to teach him other ways? This is what the ppl of the middle east saw. This is a partly why they dont trust america.

9/11 was a terrible thing, and I dont support an action like that. Never have and never will. I too was unfortunate to see the whole thing on TV, and I will never forget what I saw. But I wasnt surprised it happened. And the following attack on Afghanistan was justified.


Title: Re:Are you a Draft doger?
Post by: BFG on September 25, 2004, 12:59:41 am

Quote
And ... what did ya president do in the first min after the WTC bombing ... oups... hell yeah. he went ahead reading a book for the little childrens. How cute.

Don't forget the golfing holiday... the monkey went golfing.

Iraq had nothing to do with the war on terrorism. There were no weapons of mass destruction, maybe weapons of Miss Direction....

Going to war with these country's dosn't solve the problem. You can't storm into Afganistan and blow up half hte ocuntry and expect it all to be fine. It might have looked great to the folks back home in the mid west seeing their boys parachuting into Afganistan to go blow up some bad dudes... but amazingly enough its what you do after the fighting - its how you help the people rebuild their country, its how you support and aid the population that matters, thats how you fight these wars - thats how you fight this hatred...

Oh and you lock up fantatical religouse fundamentalits in the interest of well everyone else... Jesus if GS came over here i think he would probably be sectioned under the mental health act... or arrested